Best Supernatural Games Under $5
The 25 highest-rated supernatural games you can get for under $5, ranked by Steam reviews, with the cheapest key across 21 stores.
- #197% of 641 Steam reviews
2014The Blackwell Epiphany
$9.99 -75%$2.49kinguin & 7 storesAdventurePoint & ClickIndieSteam97%Achieve18DeckplatinumView All Prices$9.99 -75%$2.49kinguin & 7 stores - #297% of 387 Steam reviews
2011The Blackwell Deception
$9.99 -77%$2.23kinguin & 6 storesPoint & ClickAdventureIndieSteam97%Achieve18DeckgoldView All Prices$9.99 -77%$2.23kinguin & 6 stores - #392% of 4,214 Steam reviews
2001Return to Castle Wolfenstein
$4.99 -49%$2.50driffle & 21 storesFPSActionClassicSteam92%DeckgoldView All Prices$4.99 -49%$2.50driffle & 21 stores - #496% of 382 Steam reviews
2009The Blackwell Convergence
$4.99 -68%$1.57kinguin & 4 storesPoint & ClickAdventureIndieSteam96%Achieve12DeckplatinumView All Prices$4.99 -68%$1.57kinguin & 4 stores - #594% of 726 Steam reviews
2023Conrad Stevenson's Paranormal P.I.
$9.99 -75%$2.41difmark & 8 storesPsychological HorrorSupernaturalHorrorSteam94%Achieve37DeckgoldView All Prices$9.99 -75%$2.41difmark & 8 stores - #693% of 922 Steam reviews
2014Year Walk
$5.99 -44%$3.35GameBoost & 9 storesDarkAdventureAtmosphericSteam93%Achieve10DeckplatinumView All Prices$5.99 -44%$3.35GameBoost & 9 stores - #794% of 453 Steam reviews
2007Blackwell Unbound
$4.99 -56%$2.15kinguin & 9 storesPoint & ClickAdventureIndieSteam94%Achieve10DeckpendingView All Prices$4.99 -56%$2.15kinguin & 9 stores - #896% of 141 Steam reviews
- #999% of 83 Steam reviews
- #1095% of 180 Steam reviews
- #1195% of 180 Steam reviews
- #12100% of 51 Steam reviews
2023Varney Lake
$9.99 -93%$0.68kinguin & 10 storesAdventureInteractive FictionSupernaturalSteam100%Achieve30DeckpendingView All Prices$9.99 -93%$0.68kinguin & 10 stores - #1397% of 91 Steam reviews
2018Midnight Scenes Episode 2: The Goodbye Note
$3.99 -35%Historic Low $2.59steamPoint & ClickAdventureSupernaturalSteam97%DeckplatinumView All Prices$3.99 -35%Historic Low $2.59steam - #1497% of 91 Steam reviews
2020Midnight Scenes Ep.2: The Goodbye Note - Special Edition
$3.99 -35%Historic Low $2.59steamPoint & ClickAdventureSupernaturalSteam97%DeckpendingView All Prices$3.99 -35%Historic Low $2.59steam - #1595% of 117 Steam reviews
2024Midnight Scenes: A Safe Place
$5.99 -30%Historic Low $4.19steamPoint & ClickAdventureSupernaturalSteam95%Achieve8DeckpendingView All Prices$5.99 -30%Historic Low $4.19steam - #1692% of 212 Steam reviews
- #1794% of 123 Steam reviews
2025Haunted Room: 205
$5.99 -30%$4.19steam & 1 storeFirst-PersonSimulationHorrorSteam94%Achieve5View All Prices$5.99 -30%$4.19steam & 1 store - #1888% of 985 Steam reviews
2006The Blackwell Legacy
$4.99 -52%$2.37kinguin & 10 storesPoint & ClickAdventureIndieSteam88%Achieve8DeckplatinumView All Prices$4.99 -52%$2.37kinguin & 10 stores - #1992% of 156 Steam reviews
2017Midnight Scenes: The Highway
$3.99 -25%$2.99steamPoint & ClickAdventureSupernaturalSteam92%Achieve4DeckplatinumView All Prices$3.99 -25%$2.99steam - #2090% of 238 Steam reviews
2024Enigma of Fear
$29.99 -85%$4.20driffle & 24 storesMysteryInvestigationSupernaturalSteam90%Achieve19DeckgoldView All Prices$29.99 -85%$4.20driffle & 24 stores - #2195% of 62 Steam reviews
2025Paranormal Night Shift
$3.99 -50%Historic Low $1.99steam & 1 storeIndiePsychological HorrorPuzzleSteam95%Achieve12View All Prices$3.99 -50%Historic Low $1.99steam & 1 store - #2291% of 171 Steam reviews
2022The Bridge Curse: Road to Salvation
$19.99 -81%Historic Low $3.73driffle & 16 storesHorrorFirst-PersonPuzzleSteam91%Achieve22DeckpendingView All Prices$19.99 -81%Historic Low $3.73driffle & 16 stores - #2388% of 319 Steam reviews
- #2488% of 319 Steam reviews
2021Rose of Meat
$9.99 -70%Historic Low $2.99steamActionHorrorPsychological HorrorSteam88%Achieve8View All Prices$9.99 -70%Historic Low $2.99steam - #2588% of 319 Steam reviews
2021Seraphixial
$9.99 -70%Historic Low $2.99steamActionHorrorPsychological HorrorSteam88%Achieve8View All Prices$9.99 -70%Historic Low $2.99steam
KrakenKeys
Find the best prices on Steam games. Our platform makes it easy to compare prices across retailers, helping you save money on everything from popular new releases to indie favourites.
With regularly updated prices and a simple, no-nonsense interface, we make it easy to grow your gaming library without overspending.
Browse
Contact
